skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Mead/Macdougal/Clifford
I would like to comment on some of the techniques used in the MacDougal & MacDougal film in relation to authorship, experience, and what Clifford calls “interpretive anthropology.” In Trance and Dance in Bali, it is quite obvious that Mead tells their story as she assigns meaning to the images on the screen, adds emphasis where she deems fit, and creates a distance between herself, the people in the film, and then likewise the audience. She does so by delivering their story in her words, her tone; Mead assumes the position of an all-knowing, omnipresent voice, which has the power to break down just what it is you are watching.
In the Predicament of Culture, Clifford poses the question, how do field-notes, how does messiness translate into an account, into something with value to others? How can an anthropologist prove their position in relation to the subjects/matters in the film? What process needs to be deployed (implied or actually on screen) in order for a “genuine” authorship to manifest? I think the answer to this question is exhibited in the MacDougal & MacDougal film. Unlike the Mead film, theirs offered a much richer introduction to all the players involved.
Going along with visual anthropology, they introduce themselves to the audience in relation to their participants by way of photographs. They ask their informants, what would you do? How would you like for yourselves to be portrayed, in what snippets? (Through which signs, through which codes, which text- which vulnerabilities to expose.) This exercise is in itself a telling one, prompting someone to tell you what they think is important about their own lives.
At one point, when they film their informants filming, they are bringing to the forefront the very, at times, troubling, and yet quiet issue in doing ethnographic work – how can they tell a story without at least conceding first, it is not the raw perspective and emotionality that they are delivering, but rather it is them as producers of the visual; interpreting and offering what they see. Not only was this part of the film clever, but also brought to the surface the very complicated nature of the issue of authorship in conjunction with a multiplicity of perspectives.
In considering the choices both teams of anthropologists made in each film, what surfaces as particularly contentious are the techniques which appear to reveal just how much they have the ability to formulate and then construct a story as they see appropriate. It is in the narration. It is in the editing. It is in so many of the details that makes a text believable, seemingly not tampered with. In both films, it is evident that anthropologists have the power to prescribe the lived experience of others in a way that can be considered an account both exploitative of and empowering for the participants. How much are the anthropologists telling the story? How much voice do the participants have? Is the story a composite of both experiences? When working with material in the form of oral history how can one accurately portray a group of people or an individual without passing judgment on the truth-value of statements?
Are anthropologists only there to relay the story of others, or are they suspended in a space between author and participant, using their confusion and curiosity as license to maneuver and deliver a story in the form of implicitly packed commentary? There is a serious debate lodged at the core of these questions: who is telling the story, whose stories do not get told, and who is sitting in which chair behind which camera that has therefore earned the authority to make these calls? Are the silences, that which is not made explicit in the films, a site that we can unveil some of the dangers of ethnographic film? It is in the lack of conceding the relationship the ethnographer may or may not have with participants that assumptions rise and the legitimacy of authorship breaks.