Tuesday, December 18, 2007
Monday, December 17, 2007
try to keep our eye on the big picture. picture keeps getting bigger.
available for consumption
commentary for video essay
For this project I sought to address a particular statement written by Donna Harroway in Teddy Bear Patriarchy. She says, “I would like to consider in greater detail the question of story telling. In particular, whose stories appear and disappear in the web of social practices that constitute Teddy Bear Patriarchy?” With her piece in mind I found the museum’s system of classification, particularly signs both containing information about the museum’s space as well as ones that served to explain exhibits, fascinating. I felt that the choices of words and aesthetic for most of the signs to act as a telling map of the larger ideology of the museum. In my video essay, I hope to relay the experience of being in the museum- the experience of being stimulated and surrounded by artifacts and commentary, some as explicitly historical and natural, others as perhaps more quiet examples of cultural commentary.
In conjunction with the video essay I would like to ask, what is the larger story being told here? (And how blatant is that to the mind that is coming to learn about natural history?) I wanted to engage the juxtaposition of the use of general terms and details as both functioning as testament (somehow) to cultural history. (to the facts?) I wanted to showcase the museum’s ability to call its self the American, Natural history museum without showing much about Americanness and its said history, but about where humans as a species have come from. How are tribes of people in Africa showcased in the same vein as the dinosaurs are? Why is it that both of these exhibits constitute an American, Natural history? I hope that my project addresses the museum as a controversial site, an intersection of nature, authenticity, and systematic thinking as all components that must be considered beyond face value.
I was particularly taken with the role of physical bodies on display through out the museum. I think this could be attributed to starting out in the Akeley wing where with every single diarama I found myself reminding myself that the animals I was looking at were once alive, living and breathing. I literally spent most of the rest of my trip around the museum (in almost all the wings) asking myself if what I was seeing was real. (even when something clearly looked plastic.) I am so discomforted by the African Peoples wing, I almost cannot articulate it- the experience of seeing “fake” human bodies inside of glass boxes, denied their eyes makes me squirm. I think about the manikins displaying clothing behind glass windows in stores and how they are almost supposed to be invisible. It is not about the manikins (they are usually awkward and not really depicting a realistic form anyways,) it is about the clothing; the stuff; that which can be consumed for whatever the price tag says. And so, when it comes to the museum I wonder if the fake human bodies are to be invisible? I don’t think they are meant to be.
And so, they are game for consumption much like the stuff; the artifacts, the objects. Much like the giraffes and monkeys. They are stripped of their actual (past) livelihood and reassigned the purpose of exhibiting a particular story. (And so what happens when there is more than one story? Is there any room for cultural messiness? Is there a danger in categorizing that which [in my opinion] cannot be classified? Beauty, truth, faith.) And so culture is static, fixed, bounded- it is easy to digest, especially because it isn’t actually culture in the end (which would be afterall a much better field in which to justify multiplicity,) but here, we are talking about natural, history.
ginsburg and masayesva; what it means to see ‘with a native eye’
objects becoming subjects and subjects becoming objects
In “The Parallax Effect,” Faye Ginsburg draws our attention to space that supposedly divides an author from its audience. As we see evident in Victor Masayesva’s films, indigenous media provokes a whole different set of issues to consider. In someone claiming themselves as part of a group how might the legitimacy of a project be compromised? (On the one hand, I could see a project seeming more ‘real’ and on the other hand seeming more like a ‘personal quest’ project. Maybe this is the same thing.) Is the authority greater when someone who claims membership of a culture does work on it? Are there components or practices that are bound to be overlooked or accordingly some that would be over emphasized? (Would this perhaps be happening anyway, for an ethnographer that does not claim membership in a culture?) What are some of the pluses and minuses to doing work on your own culture?
Again, it seems to be a complicated choice. On the one hand, an ethnographer- filmmaker could have great access, understanding and investment in a group of people. On the other hand, an ethnographer- filmmaker might lack perspective and the knowledge that can come along with distancing one’s self from a subject or matter. Along the same avenues that Barabara Myerhoff took us down, authors in this case are doing ethnographic work in a different type of way; that is they are deviating almost completely from “self vs. other” dynamic, by working through media on their own cultural group they are sliding themselves into the slot of the ‘other,’ allowing for perhaps greater analysis.
With this being said, I would argue in support of Ginsburg’s ideas for ethnographic film in conjunction with indigenous media as a form that can create space for greater and richer documentation of culture. The idea of this attitude toward media production as premised on the object becoming a subject, moving toward agency and self-recognition can only further anthropology’s need to move away from some of its oldest tendencies. What might be lost in this style of filmmaking is a film’s ability to reach a larger audience taking an informative, almost scientific attitude rather then trying to relay experience through looser storytelling for example. What can we get out of a film like Itam Hakim, Hopiit? I think that we can get a whole lot out of it, if we can loosen our minds a little from the conditioned, wired feeling of information and its meaning being dished out to us as audience members. I like this style of film as it actually brought me close to their reality, allowing the image/audio relationship to be one that transcended my position as well as theirs but in some ways allowed me to create my own story. (Which is of course a play on the whole film being one long storytelling adventure continually unfolding in starts and stops of images and voiceovers.) This kind of filmmaking calls for much greater audience interaction as it includes the audience member in the experience by not isolating it with explicit, cut and dry meaning that would clearly delineate who is an insider, and likewise who is an outsider.
See link below:
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A07E2D71239F930A35752C1A9619C8B63
Number Our Days: Insider vs. Outsider
During the time that Barbara Myerhoff sought to create her film Number Our Days she was taking a chance. She had been conducting ethnographies up until that point on groups of people who she did not identify herself with most likely, creating a helpful distance to comment without much personal investment. In the beginning of the film, Myerhoff (through her own narration) confesses that she was unsure if this project was anthropology or a project of personal quest. I think that herein lies an ongoing debate that we have touched upon through out the semester: for whom do we conduct these projects? Are we conducting these projects to simply make a point, kill a curiosity, call for change?
It seems that ethnographies can, in certain instances, attempt to fulfill all these things. It seems that Number Our Days was a film that attempts to provoke our particular cultural understandings of death, old age, and memory. I would like to bring particular attention to just how much Myerhoff was a part of the visual aspect of this project, as she not only inserted her commentary to the camera through out the film but was in a large amount of seemingly intentional shots. And yet, even with her total upfront-ness regarding her reasons for doing the project, her expectations and personal emotional sentiment toward her subjects- there was still this act of her bestowing agency upon the elderly in her film. With that being said, I really appreciated this style of ethnographic filmmaking as it highlighted subject/subject relationships.
What is particularly compelling about the choices Myerhoff makes in the film is the consistent time the audience has with her as she reflects and unravels the experience and process of what it means to conduct this kind of ethnographic work. Everyone wants reflexivity, everyone wants (I’m generalizing now) for the author to confess his of her standpoint in the preface or introduction, and Myerhoff does this for the most part, successfully. Was this an activist film? I don’t think so. I think it was provocative, I think it most definitely calls for the audience to rethink their stereotypes, the meaning of life, etc. but I think it is more so innovative in form then activist. I commend Barbara Myerhoff and would be curious to read some of her work.
(fyi) The Israel Levin Senior Adult Center is currently listed on the UCLA resource directory for the aging as operating.
Haraway and Clifford: museum construction and its implications
The first trip to the American Natural History museum proved to be quite eye-opening. Although I have been to other museums before (yes, it’s true) I began to understand the overall project of this museum as particularly relevant and important for evaluation. Walking around the halls, I became particularly taken with the signs, their choices of words, placement and style. I became interested in trying to understand how it is that all the ethnographic films and documentaries we have been watching in our class thus far are texts that can act as documentation of culture, of particular historical narratives. Then, how is it that the boxes in the museum too could be considered cultural art and/or artifact? In “Teddy Bear Patriarchy,” Donna Haraway discusses the insistence of Akeley to use whole animals to comment on whole groups and therefore nature’s truth. So that it is the fragments, the pieces that seem to be representative of a larger wholeness. Much like the way interviews, or singular oral histories can come to speak for a group of people, to claim a particular truth. I tried to search out similarities to counteract my immediate inclination to classify the museum as a (stealthy) corrupt and elitist project.
What I realized in working through the content of the museum and its very particular stylistic choices is the lack of agency of the objects, people they represent, and the simulated human bodies themselves have, to talk back. As Clifford so aptly puts it in “On Collecting Art and Culture,” “Whose memory? For what purposes?” (248) to point to the larger tension packed in every nook and cranny of that museum: for whom does this museum exist? On the one hand, you can employ a rather surface argument, saying that this museum is spreading knowledge or some information to those that are totally not in tune with the concept of our planet including a large array of people, groups, nations and cultures. On the other hand, you can kick that argument down by conceding that the problematic lodged at the core of the American Natural History Museum isn’t that it isn’t trying to teach, but how it is trying to teach: (how do textbooks in most public schools try to teach?) How do one-dimensional histories, told from the perspective of the omnipresent white American male gaze/voice further understanding of cultural difference?
It reinstates a system that has no room for cultural mess, for complex and difficult histories. But rather, highlights the memories of other people through very narrow systems of thinking, through systems which the teddy bear patriarchy crew deem appropriate. (through systems which if you ask me, foster a greater inclination to separate one’s self from one’s different neighbor: the human body, lodged, still, unable to move, a completely picturesque moment of total difference and threat.) The quotes that greet you upon entering the main building are titled as follows: nature, manhood, youth, and the state. I am not sure which section of quotes speaks more to the overall project of the museum and its existence. But I would like to call specific attention to the placement of the word truth on the front of the museum building. Whose truth? For what purpose?
I would not argue for the demolition of the museum by any means. I don’t think I have a problem with the concept of a museum on a general level. I think that with Clifford and Haraway in mind, it is almost impossible to walk around those spaces, not critically engaging with what is presented to me. What kind of historical narrative is being constructed here? And who might be benefiting from those very particular choices? It is in the display, that which goes behind and likewise not behind glass that reinstates an understanding of culture and identity as fixed. I see suspicion, I see a lurking uncertainty called out on the human body. I wonder why I don’t see anyone who looks like me on the other side of the glass, I wonder why it is an American, Natural history when we are talking about culture of otherness.
M. Meade Festival
how can we extract ethnography from documentary and documentary from ethnography?
(can we?)
In considering The Birthday in relation to The Art of Regret, it seems appropriate to pose the question of whether or not we can draw distinctions between ethnographic filmmaking and documentary anymore? On the one hand I consider the Art of Regret to fit much better with my understanding of ethnographic film, but that very well could be because I know a MacDougal was the creator of it. The Birthday seems to fit more with my understanding of documentary film as it poses some much larger political questions, at times seemingly offering an argument to the audience.
Is it in the methodology? What can actually differentiate the two genres that are becoming more and more like one another? I wonder if a fair standard would be deciphering the role the creator/author considers him or herself to be. If someone claims themselves to be an ethnographer, then so be it an ethnographic film. Although this idea seems relatively logical there is something tremendously unsatisfying about it.
I wonder if this constant run around to classify one as not the other is all premised on our need to put into boxes what does not belong bounded and fixed. Perhaps this is analogous to the very paradox within cultural studies: the need to talk about that which cannot be bound or static in hopes of pinning it down just for long enough to finally capture it.
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
Ethnographic Filmmaking and Its Ever-Present Paradox
The Camera and the Man is a beautifully written piece that engages multiple components of doing ethnographic film. Rouch starts with a very clever point, suggesting that ethnographic film as a genre is increasingly problematized, decreasingly crystallized, and between these two things remains a rapidly producing field. He offers up an equally clever explanation by saying that it is the merits of ethnographic film that warrant its critiques. Just in his opening points it seems Rouch raises one of the main curiosities regarding ethnographic filmmaking: what is it and what is it not? Do we only know it when we see it or experience it? Can we only locate examples that are close to being ethnographic films, but then manage to fall short somehow?
I appreciated his comments on music, narration, and a call to pass media/technology skills to anthropologists as a must. I equally appreciated his comments on the movement, “real” feel of the camera when working without a tripod. Springing out from these comments he poses the question of what is the “better” way to do ethnographic film work: the Flaherty way or the Vertov way? To stage the reality or to capture a “spontaneous” moment as representative of the way things are? Jaguar serves as a rich example of this debate as it seems to me that both trends are evident through out the movie. It harbored a really chaotic tempo, a back and forth feel, as there were moments in which you could tell the subjects were not explicitly acting and there was just these seemingly natural smiles and stares captured, whereas there were mostly moments of grandly carried out action.
From this Rouch calls our attention to the intentionality and/or purpose of ethnographic filmmaking. Somewhat along the lines of questions Clifford raises on to whom particular categories matter, Rouch asks for whom are we making these films?
“For whom, and why, do I take the camera among mankind?”
He concludes with a note on “shared anthropology” and the understanding that the people who have the power to truly “pass judgment” on your work are the subjects themselves, that the work is ultimately for them and the greater public.
I think that this answer is a very sweet, romantic idea. In offering ethnographic filmmaking as a genre that will benefit some purpose outside of the author him or herself, Rouch legitimately calls for “ethnographic films to become films.”
What might this phrase mean? Does he mean films that can be wider distribution? Does he mean attributing validity to this genre just as much as other film genres? To shed some of the authenticity and/or ethical dilemmas and simply be viewed as films that do not need to be considered with these weights? Is this idea in line with or in opposition to what he calls “cannibalistic cinema?”
Again, his ideas are really pleasant, idealistic hopes for ethnographic film. And yet somehow, it seems to me that much of his vision is counteracted even in seemingly selfless endeavors and/or projects. Now that this question has been raised in several different ways I think it might be important to reiterate its relevance to our very own projects: for whom do we do the work we do? To whom does this work matter? How might doing work to satisfy ourselves (our own curiosities, inquiries that are born out of personal experience, etc) as well as for others (classes, families, public) produce a set of problems to negotiate in a project?
Paul Rabinow, in his lecture raised some serious problems within the discipline calling attention to the 'future or Anthropology' and its very necessary (according to him) fate to change. Why does it need to change? I don't think he helped us figure out why it is that we do what we do. But rather, warned us that we must speed up the process of our projects, to consider a more "disciplined," "structured" "collaborative" approach to projects.
(Why is there this weird, murky feeling of exploitation wafting about? Not toward our subjects, but toward ourselves. An uncomfortable silence. The university world is not that much different than the business world. So we are to change the way we produce work in a pseudo-capitalist venue that is disguised as an institution premised on education and learning? Change our ethnographic work to fit the table, the lab report? Could this benefit anthropologists? Could this attitude minimize the anxiety around where and into what contexts we can take "this kind" of knowledge for it to be useful?) (Ring a bell with "Army Lists Anthropology in War Zones" much? We are useful because we can help other human beings see other human beings as human beings?)
There was something so ultra-useful, calculated about Rabinow's proposal that even if the idea of minimizing university/academic politics by way of "utilizing hierarchy," something still does not sit well. Even if the idea of rethinking fieldwork, revisiting what it means to use theory that maybe no longer applies, to question the rational for what we chose to study. Sure, but then who are we doing it for?
(I wonder what Rouch would have had to say to Rabinow's presentation.)
Breton & Clifford: Ethnographic.Surrealist.Work.Processes.Projects.Goals
In considering both Clifford’s On Ethnogrpahic Surrealism and Breton’s Manifesto of Surrealism what is evident in both, fundamentally, is their call to shake the stability of dichotomous ways of thinking. So it is not reality versus unconscious, it is not art versus artifacts. What they are calling for are much more intricate projects to be developed and created. I would suggest that there is a challenge in their work, valuable and large, that should be perhaps embedded in premises of all ethnographic work. I would like to further explore this way of thinking in relation to A Land Without Bread.
What Breton and Clifford push for is a re-conceptualization of our focus: why are we looking at statistics? Why aren’t we? Why is it that some narratives are easily classified as “reality,” while others fall under “fantasy” or “imagination?” Why might we focus on a child’s understanding of an event rather then an elders? What does it mean to put a serious emphasis on concrete things while the emotional responses that are (possibly readily) available seem too messy to untangle? (Or to compartmentalize for that matter.) It seems to me that what we can take away on a most general level from both pieces is not that one narrative can be prioritized over the other, but that they are declaring an attack against the inclination to view either the “exotic” or the “aesthetic” as neatly separate realms. (So dreams are in fact different then waking life, but can you quantify by how much?) (Can you discount all that seems like a dream, is experienced as a dream?) (Can you explain that last question?)
Unless you can reach out and interact physically with the subject/idea/emotion present (?) then how do you know what is the aesthetic and then what is the underscore of the scene? (I think) that this is what Clifford is trying to get at in his discussion of the process of making that which seems familiar strange by way of provoking one object or subjects (ability) to be singularly art or artifact. In asking what the validity of classifications are, and even further pointing to this idea of classifications being natural rather then constructed Clifford is reminding his readers that there are multiple narratives that can be told about one subject. So that by focusing on the familiar, on the seemingly mundane particulars of an individuals life the viewer is almost distanced and demanded to reconsider the possible exotic, alternate stories that can be told through this (distanced) de-familiarization?
The focus on provoking what is taken as a possible (universal?) truth opens up the space for the importance of dreams, dream-like, messy cultural, and imagination-fantasy stuff. And this is where Breton pokes his head in and says, yes of course, “…why should I not grant to dreams what I occasionally refuse reality, that is, this value of certainty in itself which, in its own time, is not open to my repudiation? Why should I not expect from the sign the dream more than I expect from a degree of consciousness which is daily more acute? Can’t the dream also be used in solving the fundamental questions of life?” Can we not look to the that which is seemingly impossible to classify, powered not by good vocabulary or shots that’ll look great on camera but by a force which provokes the whole system in which it is located?
There are several things going on in Land Without Bread. First of all the audience is forced to ask themselves what it is about the subjects that is so familiar (poverty, malnourishment, death) and yet simultaneously “other-ed” about them? They are seemingly just sad artifacts, human beings, concrete and relatively breathing attesting to their status in the world, yes? Or maybe they are actually able to call attention to much larger cultural-political issues of how it can be that some relatively intellectual people in the world of academia can digest their bodies as disposable bodies? (lack of agency without camera, not social actors without our gaze?) What comes out of this juxtaposition is a puncture that is not locating in THE other, but in the category itself of otherness.
And this is what I would say is particularly useful about the film as well as Clifford’s writing. So as Clifford concludes Surrealism is evident in ethnographic work in its persuasion to irrupt rather then bound.
This reminds me almost too much in some ways of Mary Douglas’ as well as Victor Turner’s work on conditioned thinking (we see what we are conditioned to see), that which falls in between (the liminal stage – the doorway), and that which is “matter of place” as all things that (Clifford and Breton seem to call for as well) can begin to tell reveal deep-routed cultural-political vulnerabilities about a given time and place and persons. It is not in the left of right; in the exotic or the aesthetic; in the art of artifact; it is in that which destabilizes these dichotomies that will advance paradoxes or cultural controversies to the surface.
Friday, October 26, 2007
the image and authenticity
Society is concerned to tame the Photograph, to temper the madness which keeps threatening to explode in the face of whoever looks at it. To do this, it possesses two means.
The first consists of making Photography into an art, for no art is mad. Whence the photographer’s insistence on his rivalry with the artist, on subjecting himself to the rhetoric of painting and its sublimated mode of exhibition. Photography can in fact be an art: when there is no longer any madness in it, when its noeme is forgotten and when consequently its essence no longer acts on me: do you suppose that looking at Commander Puyo’s strollers I am disturbed and exclaim “That-has-been!”? The cinema participates in this domestication of Photography- at least the fictional cinema, precisely the one said to be the seventh art; a film can be mad by artifice, can present the cultural signs of madness, it is never mad by nature (by iconic status); it is always the very opposite of an hallucination; it is imply an illusion; its vision is oneiric, not ecmnesic.
The other means of taming the Photograph is to generalize, to gregarize, banalize it until it is no longer confronted by any image in relation to which it can mark itself, assert its special character, its scandal, its madness. This is what is happening in our society, where the Photograph crushes all other images by its tyranny: no more prints, no more figurative painting, unless henceforth by fascinated (and fascinating) submission to the photographic model. Looking around at the customers in a cafĂ©, someone remarked to me (rightly): “Look how gloomy they are! nowadays the images are livelier than the people.” One of the marks of our world is perhaps this reversal: we live according to a generalized image-repertoire.
Consider the United States, where everything is transformed into images: only images exist and are produced and are consumed. An extreme example: go into a New York porn shop; here will not find vice, but only its tableaux vivants (from which Mapplethorpe has so lucidly derived certain of his photographs); it is as if the anonymous individual (never an actor) who gets himself tied up and beaten conceives of his pleasure only if this pleasure joins the stereotyped (worn-out) image of the sado-masochist: pleasure passes through the image: here is the great mutation. Such a reversal necessarily raises the ethical question: not that the image is immoral, irreligious, or diabolic (as some have declared it, upon the advent of the Photograph), but because, when generalized, it completely de-realizes the human world of conflicts and desires, under cover of illustrating it. What characterizes the so-called advanced societies is that they today consume images and no longer, like those of the past, beliefs; they are therefore more liberal, less fanatical, but also more “false” (less “authentic”)- something we translate, in ordinary consciousness, by the avowal of an impression of nauseated boredom, as if the unversalized image were producing a world that is without difference (indifferent), from which can rise, here and there, only the cry of anarchisms, marginalisms, and individualisms: let us abolish the images, let us save immediate Desire (desire without mediation).
Mad or tame? Photography can be one of the other: tame if its realism remains relative, tempered by aesthetic or empirical habits (to leaf through a magazine at the hairdresser’s, the dentist’s); mad if this realism is absolute and, so to speak, original, obliging the loving and terrified consciousness to return to the very letter of Time: a strictly revulsive movement which reverses the course of the thing, and which I shall call, in conclusion, the photographic ecstasy.
Such are the two ways of the Photograph. The choice is mine: to subject its spectacle to this civilized code of perfect illusions, or to confront in it the wakening of intractable reality.
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
specificity, degrees of real, and style
I think the answer to this might be located in his insistence that it is through film that every encounters can really be showcased, and that it is via this very showcasing that an “other” knowledge emerges. (This is to say then, that “other” knowledge, cannot be constituted through written text? Or is just harder to access?)
MacDougal pits grandiose conclusions against the details of the everyday. I fall weak to his ideas (although I find them idealistic, even romantic if you will) for kind and pleasant sceniro in which to think of the author/subject/audience actors; we are all the authors according to him.
Going along with some of Jagaribe’s thoughts, I wonder if this is what some might classify is a “more real” depiction of culture? If there is no shock, can there still be something compelling about this style or outlook? I did not locate or experience “the shock of the real” in Lorang’s way and yet feel as though I was digesting what was on the screen as some “intimate,” “particular” depiction of the subjects’ lives. Jagaribe says that “Cultural specificity, however, surfaces, in the detailed circumstances of daily life, in the rendering of reality.” (71) In this moment, stepping away from the “impact,” “emotions,” and “intensity” that can be generated from the shock of the real she is pointing to the this dichotomy of meaning and non-meaning that MacDougal gets at.
It seems that lodged at the core of these two attitudes toward producing texts (on the one hand, an intentional pull away from highly stylized film or writing to allow the audience and author to interact more directly with the content, and on the other- the shock of the real, the stylized, grandiose images or montage that will allow the reader perhaps more immediate and fleeting emotional closeness with the text- as in Bus 174 and the Man with a Movie Camera.)
A question that was raised on the very first day of class seems to have gone unaddressed. What are the difference between documentary and ethnographic film? It seems that some of these inklings might help us to unfold some of the problems in trying to extract or classify one according to the other. Is ethnographic film more “true” and documentary more stylized, or perhaps carries a more explicit argument? It was conceded that Bus 174 was not an ethnographic work, was this a temporal issue? (Did this film restore us to the world, or further the mediated social and technical distance between the self and the world?) Does it have to be an anthropologists claiming culture and claiming documentation or investigation as its purpose? What happens when an anthropologist moves into doing political work, or writing on culture as a way to address a personal/political agenda? Is the work then no longer, “scientific,” does it become documentary? It seems that the two are used interchangeably and yet are considered not the same. We know what a text is not but why is it so (seemingly) impossible to code a text as what it is? MacDougal himself uses written work to prop his discussion of film. So I will use his words that he used for another set of comments and yet seems relevant here.
For whom, and in what contexts, do these categories matter?
Wednesday, October 17, 2007
What are we looking for?
I would like to emphasize that in all of this, the success of the fieldwork hinged not so much on a determination to ferret out “the facts” as on a willingness to leave some stones unturned, to listen to what my informants deemed important, and to demonstrate my trustworthiness by not prying where I am not wanted. The difficult and politically charged nature of the fieldwork setting made such attempts at delicacy a simple necessity; like Feldman, I found that “in order to know, I had to become an expert in demonstrating that there were things, places, and people I did not want t know.” But there may be more than simple expediency to such a procedure. Too often, the anthropologist takes on the role of police detective, discovering what is “hidden,” assembling “evidence” to make a strong “case,” relentlessly probing for ever more information. But sometimes what is called for is not an “investigator” at all, but an attentive listener. It may be precisely by giving up the scientific detective’s urge to know “everything” that we gain access to those very partial vistas that our informants may desire or think to share with us. And as Roberto Kant de Lima has pointed out (personal communication), there is not reason to suppose that pursuing “the hidden” guarantees that one is going to find out the most important things- or that one is being a good anthropologist. Against the logic of the “investigation,” then, there may be a greater wisdom in refraining from the blind accumulation of “data” and the extraction of truth for its own sake.
Sunday, October 14, 2007
Otherness vs. Humanness
With this in place as a framework I would like to talk about two components of Warriors of the Amazon that I find considerably discomforting. Ramos writes, “…each ethnographer constructs his own Yanomami totality, and the tools for his construction are provided by his personal inclination as much as by the specific tool kit of anthropology from which he draws” to point to the place of the ethnographer in relation to the final, produced text as well as to the subjects. (285) The ethnographer has the power to create his/her own tool bag, his/her own vision of what a text should and should not disclose, and his/her own right to fight for it in the face of any obstacles.
Can we consider this excerpt as a hypothetical defense of the choice of the researchers and crew choosing to not get extensively involved with the woman (the mother) whom they shoot with the sick infant? If we can all walk around with our ‘personal inclinations’ dictating our research ethics and ways as much as the ‘tool kit’ that we have, how will we abide by a code with ties us together in some way? Can their (in)action be justified? Can it be ridiculed? They are researchers taking notes, not making friends. Or, they are scholars with hearts, not there to treat what they encounter as if it were taking place behind a glass wall.
Which one is it? Which one wins out?
Is there, perhaps, something slightly pornographic about filming a woman who is dying with a sick infant for personal interest, academic gain, etc without offering the help that you have easy access to? Is that expecting or asking too much of the ethnographer? Would this be getting “too” involved and possibly open up an avenue that the ethnographer does not claim to (be obligated) to go down? Relieving hardship is not the ethnographers premise, is it.
In choosing inactivity the crew and ethnographer prioritize the Yanomami’s otherness over their humanness. They remain spectators, for what? To portray the authenticity of it all? In this choice they deny their position to the Yanomami, they deny their place in the scenario and consequently assumes the place of what Ramos calls the ‘invisible observer.’ They deny themselves as subjects and the Yanomami as human beings with lives as valuable as their own.
I would also like to bring attention to the sections in which they chose to use voiceovers instead of subtitles. What was the intention behind this? What could have their reasoning have been? Accessibility? Humor? To break the barrier of a ‘foreign,’ ‘exotic,’ ‘native,’ conversation for the Western mind? What was this choice about? In their lack of technical voice, in the lack of their own sound is something not lost? Is something gained? Something significant. In watching the Yanomami converse with American accent equipped voices something very uncomfortable is happening. I am not sure why, or what, or how it is that this one stylistic? aspect can generate such an array of issues that seem disrespected or uncared for, but nonetheless (I think) there is something in this discomfort.
Tuesday, October 9, 2007
Commentary on Sock-Guy
Meet Sock-Guy. Sock-Guy’s territory mostly consists of 7th Avenue in Park Slope. He has been spotted on 5th Avenue by some, not myself. He literally walks up and down 7th Avenue with a limp leg, approaching people, offering them socks in exchange for money. He carries them around in a big, black plastic bag. He enters restaurants, bars, and shops to try and sell people socks. He is Sock-Guy.
I originally got to know Sock-Guy because I would have to ask him to leave the coffee shop I work at, located on 7th Avenue. I would watch him come in, approach customers while they were reading, working, and socializing with absolutely no hesitation or hostility in his manner to offer them socks. It was always really interesting to see how people would respond to his approach; sometimes it was the ignore, sometimes it was the uncomfortable “no, thanks” smile, sometimes it was confusion and disgust on their faces. How prevalent is this type of business nowadays with massive department stores and malls almost everywhere you turn? What is it that keeps Sock-Guy going?
When I’ve decided to call him “Sock-Guy,” that is in fact who he is to people who live in the slope. I have not seen him sell any other items. He is always calm and friendly. He even sells some socks from time to time. He has tried to sell me socks. He has pink-toed ones for women and blue-toed ones for men. He’ll push and push for a good two minutes, until you really communicate that you are not about to purchase socks from him and then abruptly he shoves the socks back into the bag and says “ok, goodnight.”
I have always been curious about him. Where is he from? What is his native language? How did he end up/come to live/wonder the slope? Where do his socks come from? Is there a whole network of other Sock-Guys? Does he sell anything else? How long has he been doing this for? How much monetary support could he be deriving from this business?
He breaks social boundaries in many ways. He goes up to people while they’re eating in outdoor parts of restaurants and literally walks right up to them and offers them socks. He usually suggests that you touch them and hold them, and then he’ll put a price out there. There is nothing corrupt in his nature and yet he is adamantly ignored and rejected.
Why socks? Why this guy? There is something so bizarre in the assignment of these two pieces together. And yet, I wouldn’t call it random. I wouldn’t belittle the connection either, as this is obviously a large part of Sock-Guy’s existence, or so it would appear anyway.
Sock-Guy is a useful template to understand perhaps the society in which he is operating, since he does not fit into a socially accepted role, but challenges them.
Sock-Guy is maybe? what some might classify as the “dirt,” of the system in which we’re living. He is begging, he appears to be possibly homeless, he is unable to communicate in English well, he walks up and down an avenue with a limp leg. (And yet, he too is a consumer, as he tells me at some point right before turning into a deli “I smoke cigarettes too.”) And so, what can we learn about the system? Why does he not belong? And what are the criteria that can delineate those that belong from those that don’t? Sock-Guy is socially provocative in his ways because of the very system of thinking we live in, so then is he a symptom or someone who works to reinstate those that are the appropriate ones? (So that, when you are on the subway and the person who comes up to beg for change is intentionally ignored –are you reclaiming your space as non-dirt or you are afraid to look at what doesn’t fit?)
Monday, October 1, 2007
Sunday, September 23, 2007
Monday, September 17, 2007
The Ethnographer; Authorship, Position, and Storytelling
In the Predicament of Culture, Clifford poses the question, how do field-notes, how does messiness translate into an account, into something with value to others? How can an anthropologist prove their position in relation to the subjects/matters in the film? What process needs to be deployed (implied or actually on screen) in order for a “genuine” authorship to manifest? I think the answer to this question is exhibited in the MacDougal & MacDougal film. Unlike the Mead film, theirs offered a much richer introduction to all the players involved.
Going along with visual anthropology, they introduce themselves to the audience in relation to their participants by way of photographs. They ask their informants, what would you do? How would you like for yourselves to be portrayed, in what snippets? (Through which signs, through which codes, which text- which vulnerabilities to expose.) This exercise is in itself a telling one, prompting someone to tell you what they think is important about their own lives.
At one point, when they film their informants filming, they are bringing to the forefront the very, at times, troubling, and yet quiet issue in doing ethnographic work – how can they tell a story without at least conceding first, it is not the raw perspective and emotionality that they are delivering, but rather it is them as producers of the visual; interpreting and offering what they see. Not only was this part of the film clever, but also brought to the surface the very complicated nature of the issue of authorship in conjunction with a multiplicity of perspectives.
In considering the choices both teams of anthropologists made in each film, what surfaces as particularly contentious are the techniques which appear to reveal just how much they have the ability to formulate and then construct a story as they see appropriate. It is in the narration. It is in the editing. It is in so many of the details that makes a text believable, seemingly not tampered with. In both films, it is evident that anthropologists have the power to prescribe the lived experience of others in a way that can be considered an account both exploitative of and empowering for the participants. How much are the anthropologists telling the story? How much voice do the participants have? Is the story a composite of both experiences? When working with material in the form of oral history how can one accurately portray a group of people or an individual without passing judgment on the truth-value of statements?
Are anthropologists only there to relay the story of others, or are they suspended in a space between author and participant, using their confusion and curiosity as license to maneuver and deliver a story in the form of implicitly packed commentary? There is a serious debate lodged at the core of these questions: who is telling the story, whose stories do not get told, and who is sitting in which chair behind which camera that has therefore earned the authority to make these calls? Are the silences, that which is not made explicit in the films, a site that we can unveil some of the dangers of ethnographic film? It is in the lack of conceding the relationship the ethnographer may or may not have with participants that assumptions rise and the legitimacy of authorship breaks.









