Why Do We Do What We Do?
The Camera and the Man is a beautifully written piece that engages multiple components of doing ethnographic film. Rouch starts with a very clever point, suggesting that ethnographic film as a genre is increasingly problematized, decreasingly crystallized, and between these two things remains a rapidly producing field. He offers up an equally clever explanation by saying that it is the merits of ethnographic film that warrant its critiques. Just in his opening points it seems Rouch raises one of the main curiosities regarding ethnographic filmmaking: what is it and what is it not? Do we only know it when we see it or experience it? Can we only locate examples that are close to being ethnographic films, but then manage to fall short somehow?
I appreciated his comments on music, narration, and a call to pass media/technology skills to anthropologists as a must. I equally appreciated his comments on the movement, “real” feel of the camera when working without a tripod. Springing out from these comments he poses the question of what is the “better” way to do ethnographic film work: the Flaherty way or the Vertov way? To stage the reality or to capture a “spontaneous” moment as representative of the way things are? Jaguar serves as a rich example of this debate as it seems to me that both trends are evident through out the movie. It harbored a really chaotic tempo, a back and forth feel, as there were moments in which you could tell the subjects were not explicitly acting and there was just these seemingly natural smiles and stares captured, whereas there were mostly moments of grandly carried out action.
From this Rouch calls our attention to the intentionality and/or purpose of ethnographic filmmaking. Somewhat along the lines of questions Clifford raises on to whom particular categories matter, Rouch asks for whom are we making these films?
“For whom, and why, do I take the camera among mankind?”
He concludes with a note on “shared anthropology” and the understanding that the people who have the power to truly “pass judgment” on your work are the subjects themselves, that the work is ultimately for them and the greater public.
I think that this answer is a very sweet, romantic idea. In offering ethnographic filmmaking as a genre that will benefit some purpose outside of the author him or herself, Rouch legitimately calls for “ethnographic films to become films.”
What might this phrase mean? Does he mean films that can be wider distribution? Does he mean attributing validity to this genre just as much as other film genres? To shed some of the authenticity and/or ethical dilemmas and simply be viewed as films that do not need to be considered with these weights? Is this idea in line with or in opposition to what he calls “cannibalistic cinema?”
Again, his ideas are really pleasant, idealistic hopes for ethnographic film. And yet somehow, it seems to me that much of his vision is counteracted even in seemingly selfless endeavors and/or projects. Now that this question has been raised in several different ways I think it might be important to reiterate its relevance to our very own projects: for whom do we do the work we do? To whom does this work matter? How might doing work to satisfy ourselves (our own curiosities, inquiries that are born out of personal experience, etc) as well as for others (classes, families, public) produce a set of problems to negotiate in a project?
Paul Rabinow, in his lecture raised some serious problems within the discipline calling attention to the 'future or Anthropology' and its very necessary (according to him) fate to change. Why does it need to change? I don't think he helped us figure out why it is that we do what we do. But rather, warned us that we must speed up the process of our projects, to consider a more "disciplined," "structured" "collaborative" approach to projects.
(Why is there this weird, murky feeling of exploitation wafting about? Not toward our subjects, but toward ourselves. An uncomfortable silence. The university world is not that much different than the business world. So we are to change the way we produce work in a pseudo-capitalist venue that is disguised as an institution premised on education and learning? Change our ethnographic work to fit the table, the lab report? Could this benefit anthropologists? Could this attitude minimize the anxiety around where and into what contexts we can take "this kind" of knowledge for it to be useful?) (Ring a bell with "Army Lists Anthropology in War Zones" much? We are useful because we can help other human beings see other human beings as human beings?)
There was something so ultra-useful, calculated about Rabinow's proposal that even if the idea of minimizing university/academic politics by way of "utilizing hierarchy," something still does not sit well. Even if the idea of rethinking fieldwork, revisiting what it means to use theory that maybe no longer applies, to question the rational for what we chose to study. Sure, but then who are we doing it for?
(I wonder what Rouch would have had to say to Rabinow's presentation.)
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
Breton & Clifford: Ethnographic.Surrealist.Work.Processes.Projects.Goals
Dreams, Narratives, and Dichotomies
In considering both Clifford’s On Ethnogrpahic Surrealism and Breton’s Manifesto of Surrealism what is evident in both, fundamentally, is their call to shake the stability of dichotomous ways of thinking. So it is not reality versus unconscious, it is not art versus artifacts. What they are calling for are much more intricate projects to be developed and created. I would suggest that there is a challenge in their work, valuable and large, that should be perhaps embedded in premises of all ethnographic work. I would like to further explore this way of thinking in relation to A Land Without Bread.
What Breton and Clifford push for is a re-conceptualization of our focus: why are we looking at statistics? Why aren’t we? Why is it that some narratives are easily classified as “reality,” while others fall under “fantasy” or “imagination?” Why might we focus on a child’s understanding of an event rather then an elders? What does it mean to put a serious emphasis on concrete things while the emotional responses that are (possibly readily) available seem too messy to untangle? (Or to compartmentalize for that matter.) It seems to me that what we can take away on a most general level from both pieces is not that one narrative can be prioritized over the other, but that they are declaring an attack against the inclination to view either the “exotic” or the “aesthetic” as neatly separate realms. (So dreams are in fact different then waking life, but can you quantify by how much?) (Can you discount all that seems like a dream, is experienced as a dream?) (Can you explain that last question?)
Unless you can reach out and interact physically with the subject/idea/emotion present (?) then how do you know what is the aesthetic and then what is the underscore of the scene? (I think) that this is what Clifford is trying to get at in his discussion of the process of making that which seems familiar strange by way of provoking one object or subjects (ability) to be singularly art or artifact. In asking what the validity of classifications are, and even further pointing to this idea of classifications being natural rather then constructed Clifford is reminding his readers that there are multiple narratives that can be told about one subject. So that by focusing on the familiar, on the seemingly mundane particulars of an individuals life the viewer is almost distanced and demanded to reconsider the possible exotic, alternate stories that can be told through this (distanced) de-familiarization?
The focus on provoking what is taken as a possible (universal?) truth opens up the space for the importance of dreams, dream-like, messy cultural, and imagination-fantasy stuff. And this is where Breton pokes his head in and says, yes of course, “…why should I not grant to dreams what I occasionally refuse reality, that is, this value of certainty in itself which, in its own time, is not open to my repudiation? Why should I not expect from the sign the dream more than I expect from a degree of consciousness which is daily more acute? Can’t the dream also be used in solving the fundamental questions of life?” Can we not look to the that which is seemingly impossible to classify, powered not by good vocabulary or shots that’ll look great on camera but by a force which provokes the whole system in which it is located?
There are several things going on in Land Without Bread. First of all the audience is forced to ask themselves what it is about the subjects that is so familiar (poverty, malnourishment, death) and yet simultaneously “other-ed” about them? They are seemingly just sad artifacts, human beings, concrete and relatively breathing attesting to their status in the world, yes? Or maybe they are actually able to call attention to much larger cultural-political issues of how it can be that some relatively intellectual people in the world of academia can digest their bodies as disposable bodies? (lack of agency without camera, not social actors without our gaze?) What comes out of this juxtaposition is a puncture that is not locating in THE other, but in the category itself of otherness.
And this is what I would say is particularly useful about the film as well as Clifford’s writing. So as Clifford concludes Surrealism is evident in ethnographic work in its persuasion to irrupt rather then bound.
This reminds me almost too much in some ways of Mary Douglas’ as well as Victor Turner’s work on conditioned thinking (we see what we are conditioned to see), that which falls in between (the liminal stage – the doorway), and that which is “matter of place” as all things that (Clifford and Breton seem to call for as well) can begin to tell reveal deep-routed cultural-political vulnerabilities about a given time and place and persons. It is not in the left of right; in the exotic or the aesthetic; in the art of artifact; it is in that which destabilizes these dichotomies that will advance paradoxes or cultural controversies to the surface.
In considering both Clifford’s On Ethnogrpahic Surrealism and Breton’s Manifesto of Surrealism what is evident in both, fundamentally, is their call to shake the stability of dichotomous ways of thinking. So it is not reality versus unconscious, it is not art versus artifacts. What they are calling for are much more intricate projects to be developed and created. I would suggest that there is a challenge in their work, valuable and large, that should be perhaps embedded in premises of all ethnographic work. I would like to further explore this way of thinking in relation to A Land Without Bread.
What Breton and Clifford push for is a re-conceptualization of our focus: why are we looking at statistics? Why aren’t we? Why is it that some narratives are easily classified as “reality,” while others fall under “fantasy” or “imagination?” Why might we focus on a child’s understanding of an event rather then an elders? What does it mean to put a serious emphasis on concrete things while the emotional responses that are (possibly readily) available seem too messy to untangle? (Or to compartmentalize for that matter.) It seems to me that what we can take away on a most general level from both pieces is not that one narrative can be prioritized over the other, but that they are declaring an attack against the inclination to view either the “exotic” or the “aesthetic” as neatly separate realms. (So dreams are in fact different then waking life, but can you quantify by how much?) (Can you discount all that seems like a dream, is experienced as a dream?) (Can you explain that last question?)
Unless you can reach out and interact physically with the subject/idea/emotion present (?) then how do you know what is the aesthetic and then what is the underscore of the scene? (I think) that this is what Clifford is trying to get at in his discussion of the process of making that which seems familiar strange by way of provoking one object or subjects (ability) to be singularly art or artifact. In asking what the validity of classifications are, and even further pointing to this idea of classifications being natural rather then constructed Clifford is reminding his readers that there are multiple narratives that can be told about one subject. So that by focusing on the familiar, on the seemingly mundane particulars of an individuals life the viewer is almost distanced and demanded to reconsider the possible exotic, alternate stories that can be told through this (distanced) de-familiarization?
The focus on provoking what is taken as a possible (universal?) truth opens up the space for the importance of dreams, dream-like, messy cultural, and imagination-fantasy stuff. And this is where Breton pokes his head in and says, yes of course, “…why should I not grant to dreams what I occasionally refuse reality, that is, this value of certainty in itself which, in its own time, is not open to my repudiation? Why should I not expect from the sign the dream more than I expect from a degree of consciousness which is daily more acute? Can’t the dream also be used in solving the fundamental questions of life?” Can we not look to the that which is seemingly impossible to classify, powered not by good vocabulary or shots that’ll look great on camera but by a force which provokes the whole system in which it is located?
There are several things going on in Land Without Bread. First of all the audience is forced to ask themselves what it is about the subjects that is so familiar (poverty, malnourishment, death) and yet simultaneously “other-ed” about them? They are seemingly just sad artifacts, human beings, concrete and relatively breathing attesting to their status in the world, yes? Or maybe they are actually able to call attention to much larger cultural-political issues of how it can be that some relatively intellectual people in the world of academia can digest their bodies as disposable bodies? (lack of agency without camera, not social actors without our gaze?) What comes out of this juxtaposition is a puncture that is not locating in THE other, but in the category itself of otherness.
And this is what I would say is particularly useful about the film as well as Clifford’s writing. So as Clifford concludes Surrealism is evident in ethnographic work in its persuasion to irrupt rather then bound.
This reminds me almost too much in some ways of Mary Douglas’ as well as Victor Turner’s work on conditioned thinking (we see what we are conditioned to see), that which falls in between (the liminal stage – the doorway), and that which is “matter of place” as all things that (Clifford and Breton seem to call for as well) can begin to tell reveal deep-routed cultural-political vulnerabilities about a given time and place and persons. It is not in the left of right; in the exotic or the aesthetic; in the art of artifact; it is in that which destabilizes these dichotomies that will advance paradoxes or cultural controversies to the surface.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)