Tuesday, December 18, 2007

Monday, December 17, 2007

natural resources



it seems that if you click on this questions mark, you will be taken to the video.

try to keep our eye on the big picture. picture keeps getting bigger.



there are no words that can tell the hidden spirit of the wilderness, that can reveal its mystery, its melancholy and its charm
-theodore roosevelt, taken from african game trails 



social uncertainty can drive projects of ethnic cleansing that are both vivisectionist and verificationist in their procedures. that is, they seek uncertainty by dismembering the suspect body, the body under suspicion. this species of uncertainty is intimately connected to the reality that today's ethnic groups number in the hundreds of thousands and that their movements, mixtures, cultural styles, and media representations create profound doubts about who exactly are among the "we" and who are among the "they."     
- arjun appaduri, taken from fear of small numbers



available for consumption

commentary for video essay



For this project I sought to address a particular statement written by Donna Harroway in Teddy Bear Patriarchy. She says,  “I would like to consider in greater detail the question of story telling. In particular, whose stories appear and disappear in the web of social practices that constitute Teddy Bear Patriarchy?” With her piece in mind I found the museum’s system of classification, particularly signs both containing information about the museum’s space as well as ones that served to explain exhibits, fascinating. I felt that the choices of words and aesthetic for most of the signs to act as a telling map of the larger ideology of the museum.  In my video essay, I hope to relay the experience of being in the museum- the experience of being stimulated and surrounded by artifacts and commentary, some as explicitly historical and natural, others as perhaps more quiet examples of cultural commentary.

 

 

In conjunction with the video essay I would like to ask, what is the larger story being told here? (And how blatant is that to the mind that is coming to learn about natural history?) I wanted to engage the juxtaposition of the use of general terms and details as both functioning as testament (somehow) to cultural history. (to the facts?) I wanted to showcase the museum’s ability to call its self the American, Natural history museum without showing much about Americanness and its said history, but about where humans as a species have come from.  How are tribes of people in Africa showcased in the same vein as the dinosaurs are? Why is it that both of these exhibits constitute an American, Natural history? I hope that my project addresses the museum as a controversial site, an intersection of nature, authenticity, and systematic thinking as all components that must be considered beyond face value.

 

I was particularly taken with the role of physical bodies on display through out the museum. I think this could be attributed to starting out in the Akeley wing where with every single diarama I found myself reminding myself that the animals I was looking at were once alive, living and breathing. I literally spent most of the rest of my trip around the museum (in almost all the wings) asking myself if what I was seeing was real. (even when something clearly looked plastic.) I am so discomforted by the African Peoples wing, I almost cannot articulate it- the experience of seeing “fake” human bodies inside of glass boxes, denied their eyes makes me squirm. I think about the manikins displaying clothing behind glass windows in stores and how they are almost supposed to be invisible. It is not about the manikins (they are usually awkward and not really depicting a realistic form anyways,) it is about the clothing; the stuff; that which can be consumed for whatever the price tag says. And so, when it comes to the museum I wonder if the fake human bodies are to be invisible? I don’t think they are meant to be.

 

And so, they are game for consumption much like the stuff; the artifacts, the objects. Much like the giraffes and monkeys. They are stripped of their actual (past) livelihood and reassigned the purpose of exhibiting a particular story. (And so what happens when there is more than one story? Is there any room for cultural messiness? Is there a danger in categorizing that which [in my opinion] cannot be classified? Beauty, truth, faith.) And so culture is static, fixed, bounded- it is easy to digest, especially because it isn’t actually culture in the end (which would be afterall a much better field in which to justify multiplicity,) but here, we are talking about natural, history.

 

 

 

 

 

 

ginsburg and masayesva; what it means to see ‘with a native eye’

objects becoming subjects and subjects becoming objects


In “The Parallax Effect,” Faye Ginsburg draws our attention to space that supposedly divides an author from its audience. As we see evident in Victor Masayesva’s films, indigenous media provokes a whole different set of issues to consider. In someone claiming themselves as part of a group how might the legitimacy of a project be compromised? (On the one hand, I could see a project seeming more ‘real’ and on the other hand seeming more like a ‘personal quest’ project. Maybe this is the same thing.)  Is the authority greater when someone who claims membership of a culture does work on it? Are there components or practices that are bound to be overlooked or accordingly some that would be over emphasized? (Would this perhaps be happening anyway, for an ethnographer that does not claim membership in a culture?) What are some of the pluses and minuses to doing work on your own culture?

 

Again, it seems to be a complicated choice. On the one hand, an ethnographer- filmmaker could have great access, understanding and investment in a group of people. On the other hand, an ethnographer- filmmaker might lack perspective and the knowledge that can come along with distancing one’s self from a subject or matter. Along the same avenues that Barabara Myerhoff took us down, authors in this case are doing ethnographic work in a different type of way; that is they are deviating almost completely from “self vs. other” dynamic, by working through media on their own cultural group they are sliding themselves into the slot of the ‘other,’ allowing for perhaps greater analysis. 

 

With this being said, I would argue in support of Ginsburg’s ideas for ethnographic film in conjunction with indigenous media as a form that can create space for greater and richer documentation of culture. The idea of this attitude toward media production as premised on the object becoming a subject, moving toward agency and self-recognition can only further anthropology’s need to move away from some of its oldest tendencies.  What might be lost in this style of filmmaking is a film’s ability to reach a larger audience taking an informative, almost scientific attitude rather then trying to relay experience through looser storytelling for example. What can we get out of a film like Itam Hakim, Hopiit? I think that we can get a whole lot out of it, if we can loosen our minds a little from the conditioned, wired feeling of information and its meaning being dished out to us as audience members. I like this style of film as it actually brought me close to their reality, allowing the image/audio relationship to be one that transcended my position as well as theirs but in some ways allowed me to create my own story. (Which is of course a play on the whole film being one long storytelling adventure continually unfolding in starts and stops of images and voiceovers.)  This kind of filmmaking calls for much greater audience interaction as it includes the audience member in the experience by not isolating it with explicit, cut and dry meaning that would clearly delineate who is an insider, and likewise who is an outsider.

 

 

See link below:

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A07E2D71239F930A35752C1A9619C8B63

Number Our Days: Insider vs. Outsider

During the time that Barbara Myerhoff sought to create her film Number Our Days she was taking a chance. She had been conducting ethnographies up until that point on groups of people who she did not identify herself with most likely, creating a helpful distance to comment without much personal investment. In the beginning of the film, Myerhoff (through her own narration) confesses that she was unsure if this project was anthropology or a project of personal quest.  I think that herein lies an ongoing debate that we have touched upon through out the semester: for whom do we conduct these projects? Are we conducting these projects to simply make a point, kill a curiosity, call for change? 

 

It seems that ethnographies can, in certain instances, attempt to fulfill all these things. It seems that Number Our Days was a film that attempts to provoke our particular cultural understandings of death, old age, and memory. I would like to bring particular attention to just how much Myerhoff was a part of the visual aspect of this project, as she not only inserted her commentary to the camera through out the film but was in a large amount of seemingly intentional shots. And yet, even with her total upfront-ness regarding her reasons for doing the project, her expectations and personal emotional sentiment toward her subjects- there was still this act of her bestowing agency upon the elderly in her film. With that being said, I really appreciated this style of ethnographic filmmaking as it highlighted subject/subject relationships.

 

What is particularly compelling about the choices Myerhoff makes in the film is the consistent time the audience has with her as she reflects and unravels the experience and process of what it means to conduct this kind of ethnographic work.  Everyone wants reflexivity, everyone wants (I’m generalizing now) for the author to confess his of her standpoint in the preface or introduction, and Myerhoff does this for the most part, successfully. Was this an activist film? I don’t think so. I think it was provocative, I think it most definitely calls for the audience to rethink their stereotypes, the meaning of life, etc. but I think it is more so innovative in form then activist. I commend Barbara Myerhoff and would be curious to read some of her work.

 

 

(fyi) The Israel Levin Senior Adult Center is currently listed on the UCLA resource directory for the aging as operating. 

Haraway and Clifford: museum construction and its implications

The first trip to the American Natural History museum proved to be quite eye-opening. Although I have been to other museums before (yes, it’s true) I began to understand the overall project of this museum as particularly relevant and important for evaluation. Walking around the halls, I became particularly taken with the signs, their choices of words, placement and style. I became interested in trying to understand how it is that all the ethnographic films and documentaries we have been watching in our class thus far are texts that can act as documentation of culture, of particular historical narratives. Then, how is it that the boxes in the museum too could be considered cultural art and/or artifact? In “Teddy Bear Patriarchy,” Donna Haraway discusses the insistence of Akeley to use whole animals to comment on whole groups and therefore nature’s truth. So that it is the fragments, the pieces that seem to be representative of a larger wholeness. Much like the way interviews, or singular oral histories can come to speak for a group of people, to claim a particular truth. I tried to search out similarities to counteract my immediate inclination to classify the museum as a (stealthy) corrupt and elitist project.

 

What I realized in working through the content of the museum and its very particular stylistic choices is the lack of agency of the objects, people they represent, and the simulated human bodies themselves have, to talk back. As Clifford so aptly puts it in “On Collecting Art and Culture,” “Whose memory? For what purposes?” (248) to point to the larger tension packed in every nook and cranny of that museum: for whom does this museum exist? On the one hand, you can employ a rather surface argument, saying that this museum is spreading knowledge or some information to those that are totally not in tune with the concept of our planet including a large array of people, groups, nations and cultures. On the other hand, you can kick that argument down by conceding that the problematic lodged at the core of the American Natural History Museum isn’t that it isn’t trying to teach, but how it is trying to teach: (how do textbooks in most public schools try to teach?) How do one-dimensional histories, told from the perspective of the omnipresent white American male gaze/voice further understanding of cultural difference?

 

It reinstates a system that has no room for cultural mess, for complex and difficult histories. But rather, highlights the memories of other people through very narrow systems of thinking, through systems which the teddy bear patriarchy crew deem appropriate. (through systems which if you ask me, foster a greater inclination to separate one’s self from one’s different neighbor: the human body, lodged, still, unable to move, a completely picturesque moment of total difference and threat.) The quotes that greet you upon entering the main building are titled as follows:  nature, manhood, youth, and the state. I am not sure which section of quotes speaks more to the overall project of the museum and its existence. But I would like to call specific attention to the placement of the word truth on the front of the museum building. Whose truth? For what purpose?

 

I would not argue for the demolition of the museum by any means. I don’t think I have a problem with the concept of a museum on a general level. I think that with Clifford and Haraway in mind, it is almost impossible to walk around those spaces, not critically engaging with what is presented to me. What kind of historical narrative is being constructed here? And who might be benefiting from those very particular choices? It is in the display, that which goes behind and likewise not behind glass that reinstates an understanding of culture and identity as fixed. I see suspicion, I see a lurking uncertainty called out on the human body. I wonder why I don’t see anyone who looks like me on the other side of the glass, I wonder why it is an American, Natural history when we are talking about culture of otherness.

 

 

are you a new yorker


M. Meade Festival

how can we extract ethnography from documentary and documentary from ethnography?

(can we?)


In considering The Birthday in relation to The Art of Regret, it seems appropriate to pose the question of whether or not we can draw distinctions between ethnographic filmmaking and documentary anymore? On the one hand I consider the Art of Regret to fit much better with my understanding of ethnographic film, but that very well could be because I know a MacDougal was the creator of it. The Birthday seems to fit more with my understanding of documentary film as it poses some much larger political questions, at times seemingly offering an argument to the audience.

Is it in the methodology? What can actually differentiate the two genres that are becoming more and more like one another? I wonder if a fair standard would be deciphering the role the creator/author considers him or herself to be. If someone claims themselves to be an ethnographer, then so be it an ethnographic film. Although this idea seems relatively logical there is something tremendously unsatisfying about it.

I wonder if this constant run around to classify one as not the other is all premised on our need to put into boxes what does not belong bounded and fixed. Perhaps this is analogous to the very paradox within cultural studies: the need to talk about that which cannot be bound or static in hopes of pinning it down just for long enough to finally capture it.