Sunday, October 14, 2007

Otherness vs. Humanness

Aggression Begets Aggression 



One of the many sentiments that the Laughing Alligator generates is this need to re-conceptualize to what extent image-making is explicitly evident in ethnographic film. By way of Downey’s overt tampering with images and video, he is communicating his authority in the film as a product in itself. He acknowledges his place. Whether or not this was his intention, he provokes the audience to consider what it means to accept something as a text, embedded with knowledge and codes that we take to represent something ‘authentically,’ on some level. He is brining to the surface the processes involved in the production and delivery of knowledge.

With this in place as a framework I would like to talk about two components of Warriors of the Amazon that I find considerably discomforting. Ramos writes, “…each ethnographer constructs his own Yanomami totality, and the tools for his construction are provided by his personal inclination as much as by the specific tool kit of anthropology from which he draws” to point to the place of the ethnographer in relation to the final, produced text as well as to the subjects. (285) The ethnographer has the power to create his/her own tool bag, his/her own vision of what a text should and should not disclose, and his/her own right to fight for it in the face of any obstacles.

Can we consider this excerpt as a hypothetical defense of the choice of the researchers and crew choosing to not get extensively involved with the woman (the mother) whom they shoot with the sick infant? If we can all walk around with our ‘personal inclinations’ dictating our research ethics and ways as much as the ‘tool kit’ that we have, how will we abide by a code with ties us together in some way? Can their (in)action be justified? Can it be ridiculed? They are researchers taking notes, not making friends. Or, they are scholars with hearts, not there to treat what they encounter as if it were taking place behind a glass wall.

Which one is it? Which one wins out?

Is there, perhaps, something slightly pornographic about filming a woman who is dying with a sick infant for personal interest, academic gain, etc without offering the help that you have easy access to? Is that expecting or asking too much of the ethnographer? Would this be getting “too” involved and possibly open up an avenue that the ethnographer does not claim to (be obligated) to go down? Relieving hardship is not the ethnographers premise, is it.

In choosing inactivity the crew and ethnographer prioritize the Yanomami’s otherness over their humanness. They remain spectators, for what? To portray the authenticity of it all? In this choice they deny their position to the Yanomami, they deny their place in the scenario and consequently assumes the place of what Ramos calls the ‘invisible observer.’ They deny themselves as subjects and the Yanomami as human beings with lives as valuable as their own.


I would also like to bring attention to the sections in which they chose to use voiceovers instead of subtitles. What was the intention behind this? What could have their reasoning have been? Accessibility? Humor? To break the barrier of a ‘foreign,’ ‘exotic,’ ‘native,’ conversation for the Western mind? What was this choice about? In their lack of technical voice, in the lack of their own sound is something not lost? Is something gained? Something significant. In watching the Yanomami converse with American accent equipped voices something very uncomfortable is happening. I am not sure why, or what, or how it is that this one stylistic? aspect can generate such an array of issues that seem disrespected or uncared for, but nonetheless (I think) there is something in this discomfort.

1 comment:

nattieboom said...

I am so glad to know your brain will become part of the anthropolgical institution in the future. I agree completely with your critique of the NOVA documentary. One of the informants/shamans tells the us that he's receiving goods from the film crew in exchange for the footage; and yet the magical medicine of the outside world doesn't get put into the equation of what the Yanomami want from this exchange. I am so unwillingly to believe that medical intervention ( or at least an attempt, a gesture at curing an ill) would destroy a doc's claim to objectivity. Because that claim is so highly contested in the first place! And if it does, then I don't care to be objective. What is the ethnographer's purpose? To entertain millions of cable viewers? To gain financial sucess in academia? To seek justice? For me, this is one of the most vital questions at stake in our exploration of ethnography. As ethnographers in training, we do need to create a personal ethic. How many times has history condemed the "observer" alongside the perpetrator?