The first trip to the American Natural History museum proved to be quite eye-opening. Although I have been to other museums before (yes, it’s true) I began to understand the overall project of this museum as particularly relevant and important for evaluation. Walking around the halls, I became particularly taken with the signs, their choices of words, placement and style. I became interested in trying to understand how it is that all the ethnographic films and documentaries we have been watching in our class thus far are texts that can act as documentation of culture, of particular historical narratives. Then, how is it that the boxes in the museum too could be considered cultural art and/or artifact? In “Teddy Bear Patriarchy,” Donna Haraway discusses the insistence of Akeley to use whole animals to comment on whole groups and therefore nature’s truth. So that it is the fragments, the pieces that seem to be representative of a larger wholeness. Much like the way interviews, or singular oral histories can come to speak for a group of people, to claim a particular truth. I tried to search out similarities to counteract my immediate inclination to classify the museum as a (stealthy) corrupt and elitist project.
What I realized in working through the content of the museum and its very particular stylistic choices is the lack of agency of the objects, people they represent, and the simulated human bodies themselves have, to talk back. As Clifford so aptly puts it in “On Collecting Art and Culture,” “Whose memory? For what purposes?” (248) to point to the larger tension packed in every nook and cranny of that museum: for whom does this museum exist? On the one hand, you can employ a rather surface argument, saying that this museum is spreading knowledge or some information to those that are totally not in tune with the concept of our planet including a large array of people, groups, nations and cultures. On the other hand, you can kick that argument down by conceding that the problematic lodged at the core of the American Natural History Museum isn’t that it isn’t trying to teach, but how it is trying to teach: (how do textbooks in most public schools try to teach?) How do one-dimensional histories, told from the perspective of the omnipresent white American male gaze/voice further understanding of cultural difference?
It reinstates a system that has no room for cultural mess, for complex and difficult histories. But rather, highlights the memories of other people through very narrow systems of thinking, through systems which the teddy bear patriarchy crew deem appropriate. (through systems which if you ask me, foster a greater inclination to separate one’s self from one’s different neighbor: the human body, lodged, still, unable to move, a completely picturesque moment of total difference and threat.) The quotes that greet you upon entering the main building are titled as follows: nature, manhood, youth, and the state. I am not sure which section of quotes speaks more to the overall project of the museum and its existence. But I would like to call specific attention to the placement of the word truth on the front of the museum building. Whose truth? For what purpose?
I would not argue for the demolition of the museum by any means. I don’t think I have a problem with the concept of a museum on a general level. I think that with Clifford and Haraway in mind, it is almost impossible to walk around those spaces, not critically engaging with what is presented to me. What kind of historical narrative is being constructed here? And who might be benefiting from those very particular choices? It is in the display, that which goes behind and likewise not behind glass that reinstates an understanding of culture and identity as fixed. I see suspicion, I see a lurking uncertainty called out on the human body. I wonder why I don’t see anyone who looks like me on the other side of the glass, I wonder why it is an American, Natural history when we are talking about culture of otherness.
No comments:
Post a Comment