how can we extract ethnography from documentary and documentary from ethnography?
(can we?)
In considering The Birthday in relation to The Art of Regret, it seems appropriate to pose the question of whether or not we can draw distinctions between ethnographic filmmaking and documentary anymore? On the one hand I consider the Art of Regret to fit much better with my understanding of ethnographic film, but that very well could be because I know a MacDougal was the creator of it. The Birthday seems to fit more with my understanding of documentary film as it poses some much larger political questions, at times seemingly offering an argument to the audience.
Is it in the methodology? What can actually differentiate the two genres that are becoming more and more like one another? I wonder if a fair standard would be deciphering the role the creator/author considers him or herself to be. If someone claims themselves to be an ethnographer, then so be it an ethnographic film. Although this idea seems relatively logical there is something tremendously unsatisfying about it.
I wonder if this constant run around to classify one as not the other is all premised on our need to put into boxes what does not belong bounded and fixed. Perhaps this is analogous to the very paradox within cultural studies: the need to talk about that which cannot be bound or static in hopes of pinning it down just for long enough to finally capture it.
No comments:
Post a Comment