Monday, December 17, 2007

Number Our Days: Insider vs. Outsider

During the time that Barbara Myerhoff sought to create her film Number Our Days she was taking a chance. She had been conducting ethnographies up until that point on groups of people who she did not identify herself with most likely, creating a helpful distance to comment without much personal investment. In the beginning of the film, Myerhoff (through her own narration) confesses that she was unsure if this project was anthropology or a project of personal quest.  I think that herein lies an ongoing debate that we have touched upon through out the semester: for whom do we conduct these projects? Are we conducting these projects to simply make a point, kill a curiosity, call for change? 

 

It seems that ethnographies can, in certain instances, attempt to fulfill all these things. It seems that Number Our Days was a film that attempts to provoke our particular cultural understandings of death, old age, and memory. I would like to bring particular attention to just how much Myerhoff was a part of the visual aspect of this project, as she not only inserted her commentary to the camera through out the film but was in a large amount of seemingly intentional shots. And yet, even with her total upfront-ness regarding her reasons for doing the project, her expectations and personal emotional sentiment toward her subjects- there was still this act of her bestowing agency upon the elderly in her film. With that being said, I really appreciated this style of ethnographic filmmaking as it highlighted subject/subject relationships.

 

What is particularly compelling about the choices Myerhoff makes in the film is the consistent time the audience has with her as she reflects and unravels the experience and process of what it means to conduct this kind of ethnographic work.  Everyone wants reflexivity, everyone wants (I’m generalizing now) for the author to confess his of her standpoint in the preface or introduction, and Myerhoff does this for the most part, successfully. Was this an activist film? I don’t think so. I think it was provocative, I think it most definitely calls for the audience to rethink their stereotypes, the meaning of life, etc. but I think it is more so innovative in form then activist. I commend Barbara Myerhoff and would be curious to read some of her work.

 

 

(fyi) The Israel Levin Senior Adult Center is currently listed on the UCLA resource directory for the aging as operating. 

No comments: