Monday, December 17, 2007

available for consumption

commentary for video essay



For this project I sought to address a particular statement written by Donna Harroway in Teddy Bear Patriarchy. She says,  “I would like to consider in greater detail the question of story telling. In particular, whose stories appear and disappear in the web of social practices that constitute Teddy Bear Patriarchy?” With her piece in mind I found the museum’s system of classification, particularly signs both containing information about the museum’s space as well as ones that served to explain exhibits, fascinating. I felt that the choices of words and aesthetic for most of the signs to act as a telling map of the larger ideology of the museum.  In my video essay, I hope to relay the experience of being in the museum- the experience of being stimulated and surrounded by artifacts and commentary, some as explicitly historical and natural, others as perhaps more quiet examples of cultural commentary.

 

 

In conjunction with the video essay I would like to ask, what is the larger story being told here? (And how blatant is that to the mind that is coming to learn about natural history?) I wanted to engage the juxtaposition of the use of general terms and details as both functioning as testament (somehow) to cultural history. (to the facts?) I wanted to showcase the museum’s ability to call its self the American, Natural history museum without showing much about Americanness and its said history, but about where humans as a species have come from.  How are tribes of people in Africa showcased in the same vein as the dinosaurs are? Why is it that both of these exhibits constitute an American, Natural history? I hope that my project addresses the museum as a controversial site, an intersection of nature, authenticity, and systematic thinking as all components that must be considered beyond face value.

 

I was particularly taken with the role of physical bodies on display through out the museum. I think this could be attributed to starting out in the Akeley wing where with every single diarama I found myself reminding myself that the animals I was looking at were once alive, living and breathing. I literally spent most of the rest of my trip around the museum (in almost all the wings) asking myself if what I was seeing was real. (even when something clearly looked plastic.) I am so discomforted by the African Peoples wing, I almost cannot articulate it- the experience of seeing “fake” human bodies inside of glass boxes, denied their eyes makes me squirm. I think about the manikins displaying clothing behind glass windows in stores and how they are almost supposed to be invisible. It is not about the manikins (they are usually awkward and not really depicting a realistic form anyways,) it is about the clothing; the stuff; that which can be consumed for whatever the price tag says. And so, when it comes to the museum I wonder if the fake human bodies are to be invisible? I don’t think they are meant to be.

 

And so, they are game for consumption much like the stuff; the artifacts, the objects. Much like the giraffes and monkeys. They are stripped of their actual (past) livelihood and reassigned the purpose of exhibiting a particular story. (And so what happens when there is more than one story? Is there any room for cultural messiness? Is there a danger in categorizing that which [in my opinion] cannot be classified? Beauty, truth, faith.) And so culture is static, fixed, bounded- it is easy to digest, especially because it isn’t actually culture in the end (which would be afterall a much better field in which to justify multiplicity,) but here, we are talking about natural, history.

 

 

 

 

 

 

No comments: