Monday, December 17, 2007

ginsburg and masayesva; what it means to see ‘with a native eye’

objects becoming subjects and subjects becoming objects


In “The Parallax Effect,” Faye Ginsburg draws our attention to space that supposedly divides an author from its audience. As we see evident in Victor Masayesva’s films, indigenous media provokes a whole different set of issues to consider. In someone claiming themselves as part of a group how might the legitimacy of a project be compromised? (On the one hand, I could see a project seeming more ‘real’ and on the other hand seeming more like a ‘personal quest’ project. Maybe this is the same thing.)  Is the authority greater when someone who claims membership of a culture does work on it? Are there components or practices that are bound to be overlooked or accordingly some that would be over emphasized? (Would this perhaps be happening anyway, for an ethnographer that does not claim membership in a culture?) What are some of the pluses and minuses to doing work on your own culture?

 

Again, it seems to be a complicated choice. On the one hand, an ethnographer- filmmaker could have great access, understanding and investment in a group of people. On the other hand, an ethnographer- filmmaker might lack perspective and the knowledge that can come along with distancing one’s self from a subject or matter. Along the same avenues that Barabara Myerhoff took us down, authors in this case are doing ethnographic work in a different type of way; that is they are deviating almost completely from “self vs. other” dynamic, by working through media on their own cultural group they are sliding themselves into the slot of the ‘other,’ allowing for perhaps greater analysis. 

 

With this being said, I would argue in support of Ginsburg’s ideas for ethnographic film in conjunction with indigenous media as a form that can create space for greater and richer documentation of culture. The idea of this attitude toward media production as premised on the object becoming a subject, moving toward agency and self-recognition can only further anthropology’s need to move away from some of its oldest tendencies.  What might be lost in this style of filmmaking is a film’s ability to reach a larger audience taking an informative, almost scientific attitude rather then trying to relay experience through looser storytelling for example. What can we get out of a film like Itam Hakim, Hopiit? I think that we can get a whole lot out of it, if we can loosen our minds a little from the conditioned, wired feeling of information and its meaning being dished out to us as audience members. I like this style of film as it actually brought me close to their reality, allowing the image/audio relationship to be one that transcended my position as well as theirs but in some ways allowed me to create my own story. (Which is of course a play on the whole film being one long storytelling adventure continually unfolding in starts and stops of images and voiceovers.)  This kind of filmmaking calls for much greater audience interaction as it includes the audience member in the experience by not isolating it with explicit, cut and dry meaning that would clearly delineate who is an insider, and likewise who is an outsider.

 

 

See link below:

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A07E2D71239F930A35752C1A9619C8B63

No comments: